I recently read an opinion piece by Gary Taubes in the scientific journal
Nature, titled "Treat Obesity as Physiology, not Physics", in which he promoted
NuSI and repeated the statement that obesity research is a "house of cards" because it focuses on calories in/out, at the expense of studying the "hormonal regulatory disorders" underlying obesity (
1). I wrote a letter to the editor in response to Taubes's commentary, which has been published in
Nature (
2).
I'm used to seeing these kinds of claims in the popular press at this point, but to see it published in a scientific journal is galling (even if it's in the opinion section). This is the equivalent of a person who has never held an ax telling a group of lumberjacks they need to focus on cutting trees. It's part of a disturbing trend of popular writers in the low-carb and Paleo world attacking researchers, and even entire fields of research, they have little understanding of. Of course this only applies to a minority of the community, but this argumentation style smells of desperation and reflects poorly on the community as a whole.
Read more »
![Comment Published in Nature]()
Terampuh.com
Published:
2013-01-24T19:00:00-08:00
Title:Comment Published in Nature
Rating:
5 On
1234 reviews